Skip To Main Content
Montclair State Logo

Scoreboard

Montclair State University Athletics

OFFICIAL SITE OF RED HAWKS ATHLETICS

# Brooklyn (12-13,3-2 CUNYAC) -VS- # Montclair St. (18-6,6-1 NJAC)

Box Score

Brooklyn logo
0
vs
Montclair St. logo
3

# Brooklyn (12-13,3-2 CUNYAC)
-VS-
# Montclair St. (18-6,6-1 NJAC)

Team Score By Period
Team 1 2 3
Brooklyn Brook 13 12 23
Winner Montclair St. MSU 25 25 25
Date:
11/2/2024
Time:
1:04 pm
Site:
Montclair, NJ (Panzer Athletic Center)
Attendance:
194
VIEW
Match History vs Brooklyn

Match Details

Game Statistics By Set
Set Brooklyn Montclair St.
K E TA % K E TA %
Set #1 4 9 30 -0.167 15 4 32 0.344
Set #2 6 5 25 0.04 15 2 32 0.406
Set #3 7 7 37 0.0 14 8 43 0.14
Total 17 21 92 -.043 44 14 107 .280
Team Statistical Comparison
Statistic Team Comparison
Brook - MSU
Points
23.0
50.0
Kills
17
44
Aces
2
4
Blocks
4
2
Assists
16
43
Digs
43
51

Game Leaders

Brook - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Rafat, Aleah (10), Duncan, Kela (3), Gomez, Dinora (3)
Aces Rafat, Aleah (1), Steele, Emma (1)
Blocks Andrews, Meadow (4), Fan, Olivia (2)
Assists Gdanski, Sydney (7), Mulic, Amra (4), Marrero, Rhianna (3)
Digs Gomez, Dinora (10), Rafat, Aleah (8), Joshi, Ruti (7)
MSU - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Trzaska, Kasey (7), Horn, Zoey (6), Bautista, Bryn (6)
Aces Trzaska, Kasey (3), Bautista, Bryn (1)
Blocks Carcich, Emily (1), Ferri, Emily (1), Horn, Zoey (1)
Assists Carcich, Emily (42), Rodman, Katie (1)
Digs Hatcher, Emma (12), Ferri, Emily (9), Trzaska, Kasey (8)

Individual Statistics

Brooklyn (12-13,3-2 CUNYAC)

Brook - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
9 9 Rafat, Aleah 3 10 8 42 .048 0 0 1 0 1-0 0 0 0 8 0 1 11.0
8 8 Gdanski, Sydney 3 1 1 10 .000 7 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 5 0 1 1.0
3 3 Joshi, Ruti 3 0 0 1 .000 2 1 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 7 0 0 0.0
5 5 Steele, Emma 3 0 0 2 .000 0 0 1 0 1-0 0 0 0 3 0 0 1.0
10 10 Mulic, Amra 3 0 1 3 -.333 4 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0.0
16 16 Fan, Olivia 3 0 3 7 -.429 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 2 1 1 0 0 1.0
21 21 Duncan, Kela 3 3 1 7 .286 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3.0
12 12 Gomez, Dinora 3 3 2 9 .111 0 1 0 2 0-2 0 0 0 10 0 0 3.0
17 17 Mackiewicz, Magdalena 2 0 3 6 -.500 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0.0
13 13 Andrews, Meadow 2 0 0 1 .000 0 0 0 0 0-0 2 2 0 0 0 0 3.0
0 0 Fuxman, Danielle 1 0 2 4 -.500 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
15 15 Marrero, Rhianna 1 0 0 0 0 3 1 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0
Totals 17 21 92 -.043 16 3 2 3 2-3 2 4 1 43 0 4 23
Brook - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
9 9 Rafat, Aleah 3 0 0 0 8 0 1 11.0
8 8 Gdanski, Sydney 3 0 0 0 5 0 1 1.0
3 3 Joshi, Ruti 3 0 0 0 7 0 0 0.0
5 5 Steele, Emma 3 0 0 0 3 0 0 1.0
10 10 Mulic, Amra 3 0 0 0 7 0 0 0.0
16 16 Fan, Olivia 3 0 2 1 1 0 0 1.0
21 21 Duncan, Kela 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 3.0
12 12 Gomez, Dinora 3 0 0 0 10 0 0 3.0
17 17 Mackiewicz, Magdalena 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 0.0
13 13 Andrews, Meadow 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 3.0
0 0 Fuxman, Danielle 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
15 15 Marrero, Rhianna 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0
Totals 2 4 1 43 0 4 23

Montclair St. (18-6,6-1 NJAC)

MSU - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
13 13 Carcich, Emily 3 0 1 2 -.500 42 1 0 2 0-2 0 1 0 5 0 0 0.5
6 6 Hatcher, Emma 3 0 0 2 .000 0 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 12 0 0 0.0
9 9 Corso, Emerson 3 0 0 1 .000 0 0 0 2 0-2 0 0 0 5 0 2 0.0
21 21 Trzaska, Kasey 3 7 3 18 .222 0 0 3 1 3-1 0 0 0 8 0 0 10.0
2 2 Rodman, Katie 2 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0.0
0 0 Ferri, Emily 2 5 4 17 .059 0 0 0 3 0-3 0 1 0 9 0 0 5.5
11 11 Horn, Zoey 2 6 0 16 .375 0 0 0 2 0-2 0 1 0 1 0 0 6.5
20 20 Lopez, Sophia 2 3 2 9 .111 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3.0
4 4 Bautista, Bryn 2 6 1 10 .500 0 0 1 2 1-2 0 0 0 4 0 0 7.0
12 12 Merkel, Riley 2 3 1 6 .333 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 2 0 0 3.0
10 10 Curran, Rachel 1 3 1 9 .222 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3.0
33 33 DiProfio, Sofia 1 5 0 6 .833 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.0
14 14 Thomas, Lily 1 2 1 5 .200 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 1 0 0 0 0 2.5
16 16 Muuss, Camryn 1 4 0 6 .667 0 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 4 0 0 4.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
Totals 44 14 107 .280 43 1 4 14 4-14 0 4 0 51 0 2 50
MSU - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
13 13 Carcich, Emily 3 0 1 0 5 0 0 0.5
6 6 Hatcher, Emma 3 0 0 0 12 0 0 0.0
9 9 Corso, Emerson 3 0 0 0 5 0 2 0.0
21 21 Trzaska, Kasey 3 0 0 0 8 0 0 10.0
2 2 Rodman, Katie 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 0.0
0 0 Ferri, Emily 2 0 1 0 9 0 0 5.5
11 11 Horn, Zoey 2 0 1 0 1 0 0 6.5
20 20 Lopez, Sophia 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 3.0
4 4 Bautista, Bryn 2 0 0 0 4 0 0 7.0
12 12 Merkel, Riley 2 0 0 0 2 0 0 3.0
10 10 Curran, Rachel 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 3.0
33 33 DiProfio, Sofia 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 5.0
14 14 Thomas, Lily 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 2.5
16 16 Muuss, Camryn 1 0 0 0 4 0 0 4.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
Totals 0 4 0 51 0 2 50

Play By Play

Set #1 Plays

Set #1 Plays
Serve Team Brook - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score MSU - Play Description
MSU 0 Montclair St. 1 [Carcich, Emily] Kill by Trzaska, Kasey (from Rodman, Katie).
MSU 0 Montclair St. 2 [Carcich, Emily] Attack error by Rafat, Aleah (from Mulic, Amra).
MSU [Carcich, Emily] Service error. 1 Brooklyn 2
Brook 1 Montclair St. 3 [Gdanski, Sydney] Kill by Curran, Rachel (from Carcich, Emily).
-- Brook subs: Fuxman, Danielle.
-- MSU subs: Bautista, Bryn.
MSU 1 Montclair St. 4 [Bautista, Bryn] Attack error by Fuxman, Danielle (from Gdanski, Sydney).
MSU 1 Montclair St. 5 [Bautista, Bryn] Kill by Muuss, Camryn (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 1 Montclair St. 6 [Bautista, Bryn] Service ace (Team).
MSU 1 Montclair St. 7 [Bautista, Bryn] Kill by Muuss, Camryn (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Bautista, Bryn] Service error. 2 Brooklyn 7
Brook 2 Montclair St. 8 [Gomez, Dinora] Kill by DiProfio, Sofia (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Rodman, Katie] Kill by Rafat, Aleah (from Gdanski, Sydney). 3 Brooklyn 8
Brook 3 Montclair St. 9 [Joshi, Ruti] Kill by Thomas, Lily (from Carcich, Emily).
-- MSU subs: Hatcher, Emma.
MSU [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Rafat, Aleah (from Gdanski, Sydney). 4 Brooklyn 9
-- Brook subs: Mackiewicz, Magdalena.
Brook [Mulic, Amra] Attack error by Thomas, Lily (from Carcich, Emily). 5 Brooklyn 9
Brook 5 Montclair St. 10 [Mulic, Amra] Attack error by Gomez, Dinora (from Joshi, Ruti).
MSU 5 Montclair St. 11 [Muuss, Camryn] Kill by Curran, Rachel (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 5 Montclair St. 12 [Muuss, Camryn] Attack error by Mackiewicz, Magdalena (block by Thomas, Lily; Carcich, Emily).
MSU 5 Montclair St. 13 [Muuss, Camryn] Attack error by Rafat, Aleah (from Mulic, Amra).
MSU [Muuss, Camryn] Service error. 6 Brooklyn 13
Brook [Rafat, Aleah] Kill by Gomez, Dinora (from Mulic, Amra). 7 Brooklyn 13
Brook [Rafat, Aleah] Attack error by Curran, Rachel (from Carcich, Emily). 8 Brooklyn 13
Brook 8 Montclair St. 14 [Rafat, Aleah] Kill by Thomas, Lily (from Carcich, Emily).
-- MSU subs: Corso, Emerson.
MSU 8 Montclair St. 15 [Corso, Emerson] Kill by Curran, Rachel (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 8 Montclair St. 16 [Corso, Emerson] Attack error by Mulic, Amra.
MSU 8 Montclair St. 17 [Corso, Emerson] Kill by DiProfio, Sofia (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Corso, Emerson] Service error. 9 Brooklyn 17
-- Brook subs: Steele, Emma.
Brook 9 Montclair St. 18 [Steele, Emma] Kill by DiProfio, Sofia (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 9 Montclair St. 19 [Carcich, Emily] Kill by DiProfio, Sofia (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 9 Montclair St. 20 [Carcich, Emily] Attack error by Fan, Olivia (from Mulic, Amra).
MSU 9 Montclair St. 21 [Carcich, Emily] Attack error by Fan, Olivia (from Mulic, Amra).
MSU [Carcich, Emily] Attack error by Trzaska, Kasey (from Rodman, Katie). 10 Brooklyn 21
Brook 10 Montclair St. 22 [Gdanski, Sydney] Kill by DiProfio, Sofia (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 10 Montclair St. 23 [Bautista, Bryn] Kill by Muuss, Camryn (from Gdanski, Sydney).
MSU 10 Montclair St. 24 [Bautista, Bryn] Attack error by Fuxman, Danielle (from Gdanski, Sydney).
MSU [Bautista, Bryn] Service error. 11 Brooklyn 24
Brook [Gomez, Dinora] Attack error by Carcich, Emily (from Rodman, Katie). 12 Brooklyn 24
Brook [Gomez, Dinora] Kill by Rafat, Aleah. 13 Brooklyn 24
Brook 13 Montclair St. 25 [Gomez, Dinora] Kill by Muuss, Camryn (from Carcich, Emily).

Set #2 Plays

Set #2 Plays
Serve Team Brook - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score MSU - Play Description
-- MSU subs: Corso, Emerson.
-- MSU subs: Curran, Rachel; Thomas, Lily; Muuss, Camryn; Trzaska, Kasey; DiProfio, Sofia.
-- Brook subs: Fuxman, Danielle; Steele, Emma; Gdanski, Sydney; Duncan, Kela.
-- MSU subs: Ferri, Emily; Horn, Zoey; Merkel, Riley; Lopez, Sophia.
-- Brook subs: Andrews, Meadow.
Brook 0 Montclair St. 1 [Mulic, Amra] Kill by Merkel, Riley (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Ferri, Emily] Attack error by Lopez, Sophia (from Carcich, Emily). 1 Brooklyn 1
-- Brook subs: Gdanski, Sydney.
Brook [Gdanski, Sydney] Bad set by Carcich, Emily. 2 Brooklyn 1
Brook [Gdanski, Sydney] Attack error by Bautista, Bryn (from Carcich, Emily). 3 Brooklyn 1
Brook [Gdanski, Sydney] Kill by Rafat, Aleah (from Joshi, Ruti). 4 Brooklyn 1
Brook 4 Montclair St. 2 [Gdanski, Sydney] Kill by Bautista, Bryn (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 4 Montclair St. 3 [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Bautista, Bryn (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 4 Montclair St. 4 [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Bautista, Bryn (from Carcich, Emily), block error by Fan, Olivia.
MSU 4 Montclair St. 5 [Hatcher, Emma] Attack error by Gdanski, Sydney (from Mulic, Amra).
MSU [Hatcher, Emma] Service error. 5 Brooklyn 5
Brook 5 Montclair St. 6 [Joshi, Ruti] Kill by Horn, Zoey (from Carcich, Emily).
-- MSU subs: Trzaska, Kasey.
MSU 5 Montclair St. 7 [Trzaska, Kasey] Service ace (Team).
MSU [Trzaska, Kasey] Kill by Rafat, Aleah (from Mulic, Amra). 6 Brooklyn 7
-- Brook subs: Duncan, Kela; Marrero, Rhianna.
Brook 6 Montclair St. 8 [Marrero, Rhianna] Kill by Trzaska, Kasey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Bautista, Bryn] Kill by Duncan, Kela (from Marrero, Rhianna). 7 Brooklyn 8
Brook [Rafat, Aleah] Kill by Duncan, Kela (from Marrero, Rhianna). 8 Brooklyn 8
Brook 8 Montclair St. 9 [Rafat, Aleah] Kill by Bautista, Bryn (from Carcich, Emily).
-- MSU subs: Corso, Emerson.
MSU 8 Montclair St. 10 [Corso, Emerson] Bad set by Marrero, Rhianna.
MSU [Corso, Emerson] Kill by Gomez, Dinora (from Marrero, Rhianna). 9 Brooklyn 10
-- Brook subs: Steele, Emma.
Brook 9 Montclair St. 11 [Steele, Emma] Kill by Ferri, Emily (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 9 Montclair St. 12 [Carcich, Emily] Kill by Ferri, Emily (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Carcich, Emily] Service error. 10 Brooklyn 12
Brook 10 Montclair St. 13 [Mulic, Amra] Kill by Merkel, Riley (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Ferri, Emily] Service error. 11 Brooklyn 13
Brook 11 Montclair St. 14 [Gdanski, Sydney] Kill by Bautista, Bryn (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 11 Montclair St. 15 [Hatcher, Emma] Attack error by Rafat, Aleah (from Steele, Emma).
MSU 11 Montclair St. 16 [Hatcher, Emma] Attack error by Mackiewicz, Magdalena (from Mulic, Amra).
MSU 11 Montclair St. 17 [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Merkel, Riley (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 11 Montclair St. 18 [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Horn, Zoey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Rafat, Aleah (from Mulic, Amra). 12 Brooklyn 18
Brook 12 Montclair St. 19 [Joshi, Ruti] Service error.
MSU 12 Montclair St. 20 [Trzaska, Kasey] Service ace (Gdanski, Sydney).
MSU 12 Montclair St. 21 [Trzaska, Kasey] Service ace (Rafat, Aleah).
MSU 12 Montclair St. 22 [Trzaska, Kasey] Attack error by Mackiewicz, Magdalena (from Mulic, Amra).
MSU 12 Montclair St. 23 [Trzaska, Kasey] Attack error by Rafat, Aleah (from Mulic, Amra).
MSU 12 Montclair St. 24 [Trzaska, Kasey] Kill by Bautista, Bryn (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 12 Montclair St. 25 [Trzaska, Kasey] Kill by Horn, Zoey (from Carcich, Emily).

Set #3 Plays

Set #3 Plays
Serve Team Brook - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score MSU - Play Description
-- MSU subs: Rodman, Katie; Bautista, Bryn; Corso, Emerson.
-- Brook subs: Marrero, Rhianna.
-- Brook subs: Steele, Emma; Fan, Olivia; Mackiewicz, Magdalena.
MSU [Carcich, Emily] Kill by Gdanski, Sydney (from Mulic, Amra). 1 Brooklyn 0
-- Brook subs: Fan, Olivia.
Brook 1 Montclair St. 1 [Gdanski, Sydney] Kill by Lopez, Sophia (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 1 Montclair St. 2 [Ferri, Emily] Attack error by Rafat, Aleah (from Joshi, Ruti).
MSU 1 Montclair St. 3 [Ferri, Emily] Attack error by Fan, Olivia (from Gdanski, Sydney).
MSU [Ferri, Emily] Kill by Rafat, Aleah (from Gdanski, Sydney). 2 Brooklyn 3
Brook 2 Montclair St. 4 [Gomez, Dinora] Service error.
MSU [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Rafat, Aleah (from Gdanski, Sydney). 3 Brooklyn 4
Brook 3 Montclair St. 5 [Joshi, Ruti] Attack error by Rafat, Aleah (from Gdanski, Sydney).
-- MSU subs: Corso, Emerson.
MSU 3 Montclair St. 6 [Corso, Emerson] Kill by Trzaska, Kasey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 3 Montclair St. 7 [Corso, Emerson] Attack error by Duncan, Kela (from Gdanski, Sydney).
MSU [Corso, Emerson] Kill by Rafat, Aleah (from Gdanski, Sydney). 4 Brooklyn 7
Brook 4 Montclair St. 8 [Mulic, Amra] Kill by Horn, Zoey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 4 Montclair St. 9 [Trzaska, Kasey] Attack error by Rafat, Aleah (block by Ferri, Emily; Horn, Zoey).
MSU [Trzaska, Kasey] Attack error by Ferri, Emily (from Carcich, Emily). 5 Brooklyn 9
Brook [Rafat, Aleah] Service ace (Corso, Emerson). 6 Brooklyn 9
Brook [Rafat, Aleah] Attack error by Ferri, Emily (from Carcich, Emily). 7 Brooklyn 9
Brook 7 Montclair St. 10 [Rafat, Aleah] Kill by Ferri, Emily (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Horn, Zoey] Service error. 8 Brooklyn 10
-- Brook subs: Steele, Emma.
Brook [Steele, Emma] Attack error by Ferri, Emily (from Carcich, Emily). 9 Brooklyn 10
Brook [Steele, Emma] Service ace (Corso, Emerson). 10 Brooklyn 10
Brook 10 Montclair St. 11 [Steele, Emma] Kill by Ferri, Emily (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Carcich, Emily] Attack error by Trzaska, Kasey (block by Andrews, Meadow). 11 Brooklyn 11
Brook 11 Montclair St. 12 [Gdanski, Sydney] Kill by Lopez, Sophia (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Ferri, Emily] Service error. 12 Brooklyn 12
Brook 12 Montclair St. 13 [Gomez, Dinora] Service error.
MSU 12 Montclair St. 14 [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Horn, Zoey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 12 Montclair St. 15 [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Horn, Zoey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Hatcher, Emma] Attack error by Trzaska, Kasey (block by Fan, Olivia; Andrews, Meadow). 13 Brooklyn 15
Brook [Joshi, Ruti] Kill by Duncan, Kela (from Gdanski, Sydney). 14 Brooklyn 15
Brook [Joshi, Ruti] Kill by Rafat, Aleah (from Joshi, Ruti). 15 Brooklyn 15
Brook 15 Montclair St. 16 [Joshi, Ruti] Bad set by Joshi, Ruti.
MSU [Corso, Emerson] Service error. 16 Brooklyn 16
Brook 16 Montclair St. 17 [Mulic, Amra] Kill by Trzaska, Kasey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Trzaska, Kasey] Service error. 17 Brooklyn 17
Brook 17 Montclair St. 18 [Rafat, Aleah] Bad set by Gomez, Dinora.
MSU [Horn, Zoey] Service error. 18 Brooklyn 18
Brook [Steele, Emma] Attack error by Ferri, Emily (from Carcich, Emily). 19 Brooklyn 18
Brook 19 Montclair St. 19 [Steele, Emma] Kill by Ferri, Emily (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Carcich, Emily] Attack error by Lopez, Sophia (block by Andrews, Meadow). 20 Brooklyn 19
Brook [Gdanski, Sydney] Attack error by Merkel, Riley (block by Andrews, Meadow; Fan, Olivia). 21 Brooklyn 19
Brook [Gdanski, Sydney] Kill by Gomez, Dinora (from Gdanski, Sydney). 22 Brooklyn 19
Brook 22 Montclair St. 20 [Gdanski, Sydney] Kill by Lopez, Sophia (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU [Ferri, Emily] Service error. 23 Brooklyn 20
Brook 23 Montclair St. 21 [Gomez, Dinora] Kill by Trzaska, Kasey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 23 Montclair St. 22 [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Trzaska, Kasey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 23 Montclair St. 23 [Hatcher, Emma] Attack error by Gomez, Dinora (from Andrews, Meadow).
MSU 23 Montclair St. 24 [Hatcher, Emma] Kill by Trzaska, Kasey (from Carcich, Emily).
MSU 23 Montclair St. 25 [Hatcher, Emma] Attack error by Rafat, Aleah (from Gdanski, Sydney).