Montclair State's rich tradition of baseball never becomes more apparent then when one looks at the list of the school's All-American selections. Since 1966, when Jack Pruden was named MSU's very first baseball All-American, there have been 35 athletes that have won 43 plaques of honor. These following list celebrates those great athletes and their achievements here at Montclair State University.
Â
| Name (Position) |
Year |
| Scott Allan - UT |
2001 |
| Sam Angelo - 1B |
2023 (First Team - D3baseball.com / Second Team - ABCA), 2024 (First Team - D3baseball.com) |
| Gary Banta |
1975 (1st Team) |
| Greg Belson - P |
2000 (1st Team) |
| Lou Blanco - C |
1986 (1st Team) |
| Rob Bowness - DH |
2006 |
| Craig Conway - IF |
1998, 2000, 2001 (1st Team) |
| Ryan Costello - P |
2001 |
| John Cowan - OF |
1984, 1985 |
| Peter Cosentino - 1B |
2021 |
| John Deutsch - OF / 1B |
1987 (1st Team), 1988 (1st Team), 1989 (1st Team) |
| Brian Ellerson - IF |
2000 |
| Jim Fasano - IF |
1987 |
| Anthony Foti - P |
1986 (1st Team) |
| Dale Garlick |
1972 (1st Team) |
| Jeff Gogal - P |
2003 |
| Jack Haveson - P |
2024 (First Team - D3baseball.com) |
| Pepe Herrero - IF |
1987 (1st Team) |
| Leory Horn - OF |
1989 |
| Tim Johnson - OF |
1986, 1987 |
| Chris Keelin - P |
1999 |
| Dave Kennedy - DH |
1991 (1st Team) |
| Steve Lipinski |
1983 |
| Tony Martinez - IF |
1995 |
| Wayne Masters - P |
1989 (1st Team) |
| Dave McLaughlin - OF |
1982 |
| Elliot Morgan - OF |
1990 |
| Michael Nicosia - OF |
1984 (1st Team) |
| Dan Olsson - P |
1985 (1st Team) |
| John Pallino - OF |
1993, 1994 (1st Team) |
| Frank Petite - IF |
1976 (1st Team) |
| Jack Pruden - P |
1966 (1st Team) |
| Frank Rossi - C |
1970 (1st Team) |
| John Scoras - C |
1976 (1st Team) |
| Dave Wurst - IF |
2001 |
| Dan Wydner - OF |
1998 |
| Bob Yeager - 3B |
1985 (1st Team) |
| Ralph Yezza - 3B / OF |
1994, 1995 (1st Team) |
|
|
|
|
